Character discussions: Difference between revisions

From David's Notebook
Jump to navigationJump to search
mNo edit summary
mNo edit summary
Line 4: Line 4:
What character classes are people considering? The discussion on Tuesday night seemed to end up with 3 fighters and whatever I chose to be. <br/>
What character classes are people considering? The discussion on Tuesday night seemed to end up with 3 fighters and whatever I chose to be. <br/>
I've said it before, but in my opinion although they are good to soak attacks, fighters are the least important part of an adventuring party's balance. <br/>
I've said it before, but in my opinion although they are good to soak attacks, fighters are the least important part of an adventuring party's balance. <br/>
Fighters dominate combat (at lower levels) with high HP and good attack stats, but poorer stats can be ignored through roleplaying them away a lot of the time.<br/>
Fighters dominate combat (at low-mid levels) with high HP and good attack stats, but other dump stats can be ignored through roleplaying them away a lot of the time giving fighters the best of both worlds. [[User:Craig|Craig]]
I may have got something wrong, but I count *nine* out of 16 characters are some form of fighter below. That figure becomes 8 out of 11 when you count characters started from level 1.<br/>
I'm not saying any of this because I want to play a fighter, I am saying this because I want to play in a balanced party that has some mix for people to explore new ways of roleplaying. [[User:Craig|Craig]]


==Suggestions==
==Suggestions==


* [[User:Craig|Craig]] - Cleric, Druid (phb2 variant), Beguiler, Rogue - Depending on other party class choices
* [[User:Craig|Craig]] - Cleric, Druid (phb2 fast healing variant), Beguiler, Rogue, Bard - Depending on other party class choices


==Analysis of past characters==
==Analysis of past characters==


I appreciate that some people like to play certain types of characters, but I think that we should mix things up a bit. it seems to me looking back that there's little variation in the general party role for some players, meaning perhaps that others have to end up filling roles that seem necessary to fill skills gaps in the team. This is especially important when there are only 4 players (and one DM).
I appreciate that some people like to play certain types of characters, but I think that we should mix things up a bit. It seems to me looking back that there's little variation in the general party role for some players, meaning perhaps that others have to end up filling roles that seem necessary to fill skills gaps in the team. This is especially important when there are only 4 players (and one DM).


Here's a list of past characters from long-term campaigns - make of it what you will, and feel free to correct anything: [[User:Craig|Craig]]
Here's a list of past characters from long-term campaigns - make of it what you will, and feel free to correct anything:<br/>
I may have got something wrong, but I count *nine* out of 17 characters are some form of fighter below. That figure becomes 8 out of 11 when you count characters started from level 1.<br/>
I'm not saying any of this because I want to play a fighter type, I am saying this because I want to play in a balanced party that has some mix for people to explore new ways of roleplaying. [[User:Craig|Craig]]




Line 37: Line 37:
!colspan=2|<h2 style="margin:0; font-size:120%; font-weight:bold;">Bert</h2>
!colspan=2|<h2 style="margin:0; font-size:120%; font-weight:bold;">Bert</h2>
|-valign="top"
|-valign="top"
|Darren's game:|| Cayle - Fighter (1-?)
|Darren's game:|| Cayle - Fighter (?3-?)
|-valign="top"
|-valign="top"
|Dave's 1st game:|| Nerin - Fighter (1-10); Belros - Wizard (?9-?11)
|Dave's 1st game:|| Nerin - Fighter (1-10); Belros - Wizard (?9-?11)
Line 55: Line 55:
|Darren's game:|| Ironbeard - Fighter (1-?)
|Darren's game:|| Ironbeard - Fighter (1-?)
|-valign="top"
|-valign="top"
|Dave's 1st game:|| Hollyella - Rogue/Cleric (?-?)
|Dave's 1st game:|| Elvebriniel - Monk (?3-?7); Hollyella - Rogue/Cleric (?7-11)
|-valign="top"
|-valign="top"
|Craig's game:|| Finduilas - Paladin (1-?)
|Craig's game:|| Finduilas - Paladin (1-?)

Revision as of 11:34, 25 January 2009

Character Discussion

What character classes are people considering? The discussion on Tuesday night seemed to end up with 3 fighters and whatever I chose to be.
I've said it before, but in my opinion although they are good to soak attacks, fighters are the least important part of an adventuring party's balance.
Fighters dominate combat (at low-mid levels) with high HP and good attack stats, but other dump stats can be ignored through roleplaying them away a lot of the time giving fighters the best of both worlds. Craig

Suggestions

  • Craig - Cleric, Druid (phb2 fast healing variant), Beguiler, Rogue, Bard - Depending on other party class choices

Analysis of past characters

I appreciate that some people like to play certain types of characters, but I think that we should mix things up a bit. It seems to me looking back that there's little variation in the general party role for some players, meaning perhaps that others have to end up filling roles that seem necessary to fill skills gaps in the team. This is especially important when there are only 4 players (and one DM).

Here's a list of past characters from long-term campaigns - make of it what you will, and feel free to correct anything:
I may have got something wrong, but I count *nine* out of 17 characters are some form of fighter below. That figure becomes 8 out of 11 when you count characters started from level 1.
I'm not saying any of this because I want to play a fighter type, I am saying this because I want to play in a balanced party that has some mix for people to explore new ways of roleplaying. Craig


Craig

Darren's game: N/A
Dave's 1st game: Huerney - Bard (1-11); Savaric - Paladin of Freedom (10-11)
Craig' game: N/A
Dave's second game: Dan - Wizard (1-12)

Bert

Darren's game: Cayle - Fighter (?3-?)
Dave's 1st game: Nerin - Fighter (1-10); Belros - Wizard (?9-?11)
Craig's game: Berrawyn - Ranger (1-?)
Dave's second game: Adrin - Barbarian/Fighter (1-12)


Hannele

Darren's game: Ironbeard - Fighter (1-?)
Dave's 1st game: Elvebriniel - Monk (?3-?7); Hollyella - Rogue/Cleric (?7-11)
Craig's game: Finduilas - Paladin (1-?)
Dave's second game: Aliatra - Fighter/Cleric (1-12)

Delphine

Darren's game: N/A
Dave's 1st game: Ayhlanne - Ranger (1-11)
Craig's game: Farkenella - Thief (1-?)
Dave's second game: Lia - Druid (1-?6); Oona - Rogue (6-11)